Learn

How do you keep a trading journal that shows what’s working?

A journal is only useful if it answers questions later. Here are the columns that do, and the weekly review that turns them into decisions.

By · Trading Decisions Lab · Updated

Short answer

Log the same 10 things on every trade: date and time, setup, direction, entry, stop, target, exit, size, P&L in dollars, and whether you followed your plan. After 30–50 trades, split the results by setup, time of day and plan-followed. That shows whether a problem is the strategy or the execution, which a P&L total can’t.

10columns per trade
30–50trades before you judge a setup
1column that matters most: followed the plan?

The 10 columns

  1. Date and entry time
  2. Setup name
  3. Long or short
  4. Entry price
  5. Stop price
  6. Target price
  7. Exit price and reason (stop, target, time, manual)
  8. Contracts
  9. P&L in dollars, after fees
  10. Followed the plan? Yes or no, and what changed

The weekly review

Split results byWhat it tells you
Followed the plan vs notWhether your losses come from the strategy or from execution
SetupWhich setups to keep and which to drop
Time of dayWhen you trade well; most NQ movement is near the open (see our time-of-day study)
Exit reasonWhether manual exits help or hurt compared with your stop and target

Don’t judge too early

Small samples swing a lot. A strategy that wins 40% of the time can easily lose 9 in a row (see the table). Wait for 30–50 trades on a setup before deciding, unless you’re breaking your own rules.

Questions

What should I put in a trading journal?

Date and time, setup, direction, entry, stop, target, exit and reason, size, dollar P&L after fees, and whether you followed your plan.

How many trades before I can judge a strategy?

At least 30–50 on the same setup, and ideally a backtest of hundreds. Fewer than that, and normal losing streaks can make a good setup look broken.

Keep reading

Cite this: Trading Decisions Lab, “How do you keep a trading journal that shows what’s working?” (Oct 31, 2026). https://www.tradingdecisionslab.com/learn/how-to-keep-a-trading-journal

Simulated backtest. Hypothetical or simulated performance results have certain limitations and do not represent actual trading; see the full disclaimer. Past results don’t guarantee future results. Educational only, not financial advice. Futures are leveraged and you can lose more than your deposit.