Compare
Five popular indicator suites. One shows its results.
Who each one is for, what you miss out on, and which ones show how their signals actually did.
Short answer
The others sell tools and leave the testing to you. Compass sells one tested plan for NQ futures, and it’s the only one of the five that shows how its own signals did. $49 a month, the price of one Topstep reset.
| Compass | LuxAlgo | Flux Charts | AlgoAlpha | ChartPrime | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best for | NQ and MNQ day traders, especially on prop accounts. Also used on ES, QQQ and SPY, but only tested on NQ | Traders who want a TradingView alternative and to build their own strategies with AI | Price-action and supply-and-demand traders who like to test their own setups | Crypto traders who want signals copied to their exchange | Traders who want lots of tools, live classes and a big community |
| What you get | One TradingView indicator: a trade plan with entry, stop and target, plus swing calls | Vela, its own charting platform: 800+ indicators, orderflow, live CME data and Quant, an AI strategy builder | Three TradingView toolkits, three backtesters and screeners | Three TradingView indicators, an AI backtester, and crypto signals auto-copied to Bybit | 50+ TradingView tools with signals, take-profit and stop levels, live classes |
| What you miss out on | A big indicator library, tested results on other markets, and a large community (it’s new) | A ready-made plan. You build and test the strategy yourself | A tested plan and published results. Testing is your job | A futures and prop-firm focus, and published results | Published results and one focused plan. You pick from 50+ tools |
| Entry, stop and target before you click | Yes · on every signal, locked at bar close | No · you build it | Partly · signals and zones | Partly · crypto signals only | Yes · signals with take-profit and stop |
| Shows how its own signals did | Yes · 5 years of NQ, after costs, every loss counted | No · its site says it has “no reason to believe” customers do better or worse than traders as a whole | No | No | No |
| Prop-firm odds for its own signals | Yes · Topstep, Apex, LucidPro, LucidFlex | Partly · a free calculator for your own stats, not its signals | No | No | No |
| Price | $49/month · free for 60 days | $24.99–$119.99/month · free plan | $59.99/month billed yearly | $28.72–$79.32/month billed yearly | $67–$117/month |
Why Compass
Five years of NQ, after costs, every losing trade counted. $10,000 grew to $106,492 in the backtest (worst drop −16.2%).
On Topstep 50K, 82% of new evaluations reached a first payout, in about 3 months (backtest). Apex and Lucid too.
One plan per setup: entry, stop and target on the chart, locked when the bar closes.
$49 a month, the same as one Topstep 50K reset. Free for the first 60 days.
On cost: some toolkits are cheaper per year, but a toolkit isn’t a strategy. While you build and test one, every failed evaluation is another reset ($49 on a Topstep 50K). Compass costs the same as one reset and shows you how its plan did before you pay anything. Add up what resets cost you.
Compare
Compass vs LuxAlgo
A platform to build on, or a plan already tested.
Compare
Compass vs Flux Charts
Toolkits to test your ideas, or a plan already tested.
Compare
Compass vs AlgoAlpha
Crypto-first, or a futures plan tested for prop firms.
Compare
Compass vs ChartPrime
Same promise; only one shows its record.
Checked on November 8, 2026 from each company’s own website (luxalgo.com, fluxcharts.com, algoalpha.io, chartprime.com, Topstep’s pricing page). List prices, before promotions. “No” means we couldn’t find it on their public pages. We make Compass, so weigh our view accordingly; corrections to TradingDecisionsLab@gmail.com. Compass results are a hypothetical backtest; live results will differ.
Questions
Which TradingView indicator shows its own results?
Of Compass, LuxAlgo, Flux Charts, AlgoAlpha and ChartPrime, only Compass published a backtest of its own signals on its site when we checked on November 8, 2026.
What is the best TradingView indicator for prop firm traders?
One that tells you where to get out and shows how it did under prop-firm rules. Compass draws entry, stop and target and shows its pass and payout rates on Topstep, Apex and Lucid 50K accounts (backtest).
Does Compass work on ES, QQQ or SPY?
It’s built and tested on Nasdaq-100 futures (NQ and MNQ). Some traders use it on ES, QQQ and SPY, but those markets aren’t tested, so treat signals there with extra caution.
Simulated backtest. Hypothetical or simulated performance results have certain limitations and do not represent actual trading; see the full disclaimer. Past results don’t guarantee future results. Educational only, not financial advice. Futures are leveraged and you can lose more than your deposit.